Writing to a Soundtrack: A Guest Post by Alexandra Y. Caluen
I’m a longtime fan of a series by Carrie Vaughn about Kitty the werewolf. Kitty works in radio, and each book leads off with a short playlist. I always liked that idea.
Since I started learning to dance I’m always looking for new music. The obvious places are shows like SYTYCD and DWTS, movie soundtracks, and ‘people who bought X also bought Y.’ But finding new music through books is also a thing.
Music is everywhere. Elevators, churches, retail establishments, restaurants. Life has a soundtrack. When writers acknowledge that, I appreciate it. To me, the kind of music a character responds to says a lot. Music helps set the scene (place and time) and the mood.
I started publishing The L.A. Stories in 2012. It wasn’t until 2017 that I started taking the whole thing seriously. My awesomesauce sister (the only person on Earth aside from me who has read all my stuff) appointed herself Marketing Guru. A website, a new and consistent cover design, and a few other things followed. One of those things was a series rewrite. I had to go back to the beginning and bring the early stories up to the level of the later ones. As I did that, I gave each one a playlist. These playlists always have something to do with the story.
There have been times when a certain song actually sparked a story idea. Chief example: ‘Iris,’ a pop waltz by the band Goo Goo Dolls, which was a hit off the soundtrack to the movie City of Angels. This song is key to my novel Lost & Found. For that book’s playlist, I narrowed the song choices to a collection of pop waltzes. People may recognize the songs without noticing they are all in three-quarter time, but it pleased me.
Other times there is a project at the heart of a story, and that project has its own soundtrack. Such a case is the novel Face the Music, in which the main characters have an important date at a narrative dance concert retelling the Beowulf story.
For a current work-in-progress novel, I’m using the playlist of another in-story project, this one a narrative tango show called ‘Gaucho.’ My main characters in the new book are not performers, but they are both learning to dance tango. It’s a thing that connects them at a time when very little else does.
When characters are performers, music tends to play (ha!) a large part in the story. It should! I don’t know any singers, dancers, or musicians who are not completely obsessed with music. My character Janis Vaughn (A Secret Chord and A Braid of Love) is a professional jazz singer and pianist à la Diana Krall. Music is huge in her stories; it has to be. Or there’s Gino Corsetti from Here to Stay: He’s a singer with a Sinatra tribute show in Las Vegas, so his playlist is all Sinatra hits.
I try to reference music that can be found and purchased fairly easily. Sometimes I fail. A recent novella about a trumpet player (Take a Note) has playlist tracks that I was only able to find via YouTube.
The irony? I can’t really listen to music while I’m writing, or while I’m logged in to the day job. It’s a distraction, because I like to listen to music – it’s not simply background for me. For a while there I had 2.5 hours a day of slow-moving car commute in which to listen to music. Right now I’m trying to think of a way to build it back into my life. Because some songs can go on more than one playlist, but I like to keep mixing it up.
I can only listen to music as background if I’m doing something fairly mindless like cooking or ironing – and then I generally listen to an audiobook anyway. This will sound odd when I tell you that I’m a musician – I love classical music but when I listen to it I want to LISTEN to it as a primary activity and not as something in the background. I can’t read or write with it on as I start focusing on the music and not what I’m supposed to be doing. I don’t know how people can have music on while they’re working; both my kids have earbuds in while they’re studying, and I don’t know how they can concentrate.
I’m the same way. If I’m doing something physical I can listen to music in the background but if it requires my thought and concentration I find music either distracting or I am just tuning it out.
Exactly. Although I find it pretty much impossible to tune out – I think my brain is either naturally, or by training, wired to pay attention to the music!
I enjoy music references in the stories I read. This isn’t quite possible in HR but in Contemporary I’ve hummed along to Dusty Springfield in Jennifer Crusie’s books. In “Welcome to Temptation” and “Faking It” the music added to the texture (not the word I’m really looking for- feel free to help) and made the story richer.
I usually can’t listen to music that has lyrics while I’m reading—my mind gets distracted by listening to the words and that takes me away from what I’m trying to read—but I will try to listen to at least a snippet of each song when a book comes with a playlist. The most effective playlist I’ve encountered was the one Pam Godwin assembled for her Tangled Lies trilogy (ONE IS A PROMISE, TWO IS A LIE, THREE IS A WAR), where I felt that every song she selected matched the mood of the particular chapter with which she paired it. Perhaps the most effective use of a single song in a romance was Natasha Knight’s use of Handmouth’s “Darlin’” in her mafia romance SERGIO, where references to the song thread throughout the book. The elegiac tone of “Darlin’” is in perfect keeping with the very downbeat tone of the book and its unexpected ending (an ending which, imho, really makes the book not a romance at all).