The AAR Seventeen in 17 Reading Challenge – June Update
Back on track this month, here’s the post for those of you who are participating in AAR’s Seventeen in 17 Reading Challenge. Check in here and share your thoughts on the books you read throughout June.
It’s still not too late to sign up – just head on over to the main Challenge page to have a look at the fabulously varied range of prompts that are sure to provide food for thought for everyone, and get stuck in to your TBR pile!
Now it’s over to you Challengers. How many books are you going to knock off the TBR pile this month?
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler)
Lady of the Star Wind by Veronica Scott: The book started strong. The heroine was an interstellar princess/doctor who’d been kidnapped. The hero was her former love who’d been exiled twenty years earlier when her evil grandmother discovered their relationship. During her rescue they mysteriously wound up on a much less advanced planet. He was resentful that he’d been tortured and forced to spend two decades living life as someone else so reluctant to let his guard down. She was resentful that he’d allowed her to believe him dead for so long. They actually talked through their issues – yay! As a reunion romance the book worked well for me. The problem was there wasn’t enough focus on their relationship. The story became all about them helping the large cast of secondary characters in their quest to defeat the usurper to the thrown of their kingdom. The book had some nice twists at the beginning, but the romance took a backseat to the political shenanigans. I enjoyed most of the book despite my issues with the plot, but the ending was so extremely anti-climactic it made me roll my eyes. I wish more page time had focused on the h/h. There were also two secondary romances I would have liked to have seen more of.
The Breakfast Cereal Challenge
Muesli (1900) = Created by a Swiss physician. Read a romance set in Europe.
The Chocolate Kiss by Laura Florand – set in France: The heroine worked in her aunts’ chocolate shop; the hero was a world-famous fifth generation pastry chef. The h/h spent the first two-thirds or so of the book sniping at one another and refusing to eat/drink anything the other made. Readers were probably meant to find this amusing and flirty, but it came off as mean spirited much of the time. The hero was an arrogant jerk and casually dismissive of others. Several characters pointed this out to him at various points. He improved somewhat in the final third, but never really changed. The heroine had childhood issues. Her parents were portrayed as totally oblivious while his were perfect (other than the father’s occasional professional jealousy, but even that was ultimately pride in his son). There were moments I liked and I enjoyed the setting, but overall a lackluster read.
~
The Breakfast Cereal Challenge: 11 down, 6 to go…
Seventeen Magazine(s)! Challenge: 8 down, 9 to go…
The Alphabet Challenge Variation: 11 down, 6 to go…
The Cocktail Challenge: 13 down, 4 to go…
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler) – Novellas: 9 down, 8 to go…
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler): 2 down, 15 to go…
The 20th Century Challenge: completed!
Seventeen Magazine(s)! Challenge
National Geographic – Read a romance in which the hero and/or heroine set off on an adventure or visit/travel to an exotic (to them) land.
The Iron Duke by Meljean Brook – h/h travel to France and Africa: There were parts of the plot I wish had been more developed. The hero’s attitude was questionable at times even after learning his backstory. His past traumas were touched upon, but the focus was much more on the heroine. I liked them as a couple, but wished that so many of their problems hadn’t been solely due to lack of communication. Especially as this caused the ending to seem extremely rushed. A bit uneven, but overall I enjoyed the romance as well as the intricate world-building.
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler) – novellas
The Blushing Bounder by Meljean Brook: The lack of communication between this h/h mas much better integrated into the plot of this prequel novella. The hero was the constable partner of the police inspector heroine in the above book. Since he stole nearly every scene he was in, I was happy to see him get his own story. The heroine started off wallowing in her assumptions and prejudices, but I came to like her. The story involved the heroine witnessing a murder and a glimpse of the hero’s first few days on the job. I really wish their story had been longer. We’re told briefly about their courtship and the heroine’s sudden change of attitude made sense, but I would have liked to have had more conversations between them. I enjoyed what there was, but the story felt unfinished.
~
The Breakfast Cereal Challenge: 10 down, 7 to go…
Seventeen Magazine(s)! Challenge: 8 down, 9 to go…
The Alphabet Challenge Variation: 11 down, 6 to go…
The Cocktail Challenge: 13 down, 4 to go…
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler) – Novellas: 9 down, 8 to go…
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler): 1 down, 16 to go…
The 20th Century Challenge: completed!
The Alphabet Challenge Variation
L = Lost and Found Sisters by Jill Shalvis: The heroine discovered she’d been adopted just before her thirtieth birthday. Yes the book was about her journey of self-discovery, but she spent the first two-thirds or so being so passive and all but one of the resolutions to her issues with her parents, ex, and boss happened off page which was extremely unsatisfying. The subplot with her parents in particular was very vexing. There were a number of additional subplots introduced and then mainly glossed over which was also irksome. Not all of the humor in the book worked for me. I wish we’d seen more of the relationship the heroine formed with her newly discovered sister as it felt somewhat underdeveloped. One of my favorite parts of the book was the heroine’s begrudging friendship with the hero’s ex. So an uneven read overall. While I grew to like the heroine it was the hero who made the book.
~
The Breakfast Cereal Challenge: 10 down, 7 to go…
Seventeen Magazine(s)! Challenge: 7 down, 10 to go…
The Alphabet Challenge Variation: 11 down, 6 to go…
The Cocktail Challenge: 13 down, 4 to go…
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler) – Novellas: 8 down, 9 to go…
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler): 1 down, 16 to go…
The 20th Century Challenge: completed!
By the way, I have no ability to post on the message boards at this time. Can’t log-in. Can’t get a “forgotten password” email sent to me — although I haven’t forgotten my password, and can’t register under my current user name because it’s being “used” — by me!
Try emailing Dabney. That’s what I did.
Plus, I think it gets kind of buried in the blog. New members can’t find it easily and less frequent posters may forget about it.
I wouldn’t mind moving it back to the message board, so that the contributors to the challenge can start it when they are ready and not have it be a monthly thing, etc.
Since we have a message board again, will we continue to post the challenge on the blog or move it back there?
Since the message boards are back, are we going to continue with the reading challenge on the blog or move it back to the board?
The Breakfast Cereal Challenge
Frosted Flakes (1952) = The mascot for this cereal is Tony the Tiger. Read a paranormal romance where the hero or heroine has the ability to shift into an animal.
Silver Silence by Nalini Singh – hero is a bear changeling: This book marked the first of the new “season” of the Psy/Changeling series, but I’ve been intrigued by the heroine ever since she was introduced back in book 3 of the original series. Even though there were a few subplots, the focus was very much on the romance. I loved the way the hero was sneaky like a cat yet still a gentleman bear. Of course the heroine more than held her own. They were a very well matched couple. I adored the bears and enjoyed getting to know the heroine’s family better. It was nice to explore a different area of the world. When the new set of villains was introduced a few books back I was intrigued even though at face value it seemed too generic and that’s still my take. I am anxious to see how one of the subplots resolves in (hopefully) the next book (trying not to be spoiler-y). Overall a very nice start to “season two.”
~
The Breakfast Cereal Challenge: 10 down, 7 to go…
Seventeen Magazine(s)! Challenge: 7 down, 10 to go…
The Alphabet Challenge Variation: 10 down, 7 to go…
The Cocktail Challenge: 13 down, 4 to go…
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler) – Novellas: 8 down, 9 to go…
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler): 1 down, 16 to go…
The 20th Century Challenge: completed!
The Cocktail Challenge
Grasshopper – Read a book where the h/h is a farmer or landscaper or florist or works with the land in some way.
Come Sundown by Nora Roberts – heroine’s family owns a ranch: The story meandered quite a bit for the first half. Though the author has written worse villains and torture scenes, I found the ones in this book particularly difficult to read. The mystery villain was obvious from the first scene they appeared in. The resolution to the subplot regarding the deputy didn’t completely work for me. On the plus side, I mostly liked the main romance or more accurately enjoyed their romance but had issues with some things both the hero and heroine did during other parts of the book. I wish we’d gotten more of the secondary couple as I enjoyed their romance even more than the main one. I liked the heroine’s aunt’s interactions with the hero’s, though I wish we’d had more scenes between her and her mother. And I adored the hero’s horse. While I really enjoyed parts overall it was an uneven read.
~
The Breakfast Cereal Challenge: 9 down, 8 to go…
Seventeen Magazine(s)! Challenge: 7 down, 10 to go…
The Alphabet Challenge Variation: 10 down, 7 to go…
The Cocktail Challenge: 13 down, 4 to go…
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler) – Novellas: 8 down, 9 to go…
Simply Seventeen Challenge (The Whittler): 1 down, 16 to go…
The 20th Century Challenge: completed!
with the hero (oops)
Continuing with the Cocktail Challenge…
First off, just wanted to say, I posted this “review” on the AAR Goodreads message board (so no one thinks they’re seeing double). I did that mostly because I thought people who weren’t following along with the monthly challenge might also want to hear about this book.
For this part of the challenge, I read Kirsty Greenwood’s The Vintage Guide to Love and Romance, published in 2015. The book fits into the British Chick Lit genre, generally, and I found it laugh-out-loud funny and touching.
The story centers on a 28 year old blogger/writer who is a true character. Unlike other women in this book – or in many romances – Jessica Beam has no interest in marriage or a relationship. She just wants to have a good time, usually involving the closest pub, partying, alcohol, and possibly, a roll in the hay. Through a series of unfortunate events and a disloyal “best friend” Jessica ends up without a home or a job. With nowhere to turn, she travels to London to find the grandmother she never knew. It doesn’t hurt that the old lady lives in a tony house in Kensington, which suggests a healthy bank account. However, appearances are deceptive and, before you know it Jessica, her grandmother Matilda Beam, and Matilda’s assistant, Peach, who reminded me a bit of Agnes Gooch from “Mame” (only with an American southern accent) have embarked on a scheme to replenish their financial coffers. It seems Matilda was also once a writer of a set of very popular 1950’s self-help books for proper women who wanted to know how to attract a respectable, accomplished man, be a good wife, a good mother, etc. — a Martha Stewart for one’s personal life. However, Matilda’s books are so out-of-date in 2014 … or *are* they? With the promise of a possible publishing deal, Matilda (and her former publisher) talk Jessica into following the 1950’s books to a tee, applying it to the 2014 dating scene in pursuit of one of the most elusive bachelors in London, and authoring the results. Will this independent, potty-mouth, party girl be able to woo a respectable, socially-connected, accomplished man following her grandmother’s tutelage and her “Good Woman” guide books? And what will she discover about herself, the family she hardly knew, and the man they’ve targeted?
Vintage Guide was definitely an “A” read for me, and I immediately googled to see what else the author had written. Through most of the book you’re giggling if not laughing loudly, but the end brings the warmth and tenderness that wraps up the loose ends. As for writing style, there’s a number of “British-isms,” but it’s very accessible with a fair amount of salty dialogue, because our heroine often sounds like a sailor. ;-) However, reflecting the more traditional Matilda, the beginning of each chapter features a snippet of advice from her 1950’s books, and additionally, throughout the novel, there are excerpts from Jessica’s mother’s diaries.
******
The Cocktail Challenge – 7 down, 3 to go.
Alphabet Challenge – 5 down, 5 to go. (B, G, H, J, & M)