The Autumn Bride

TEST

Older spinster sister to three younger sisters. Heroine who was badly burned romantically. Quirky situations and a crotchety older ham who takes sisters under their wing. Sound familiar? Well, beyond the usual Regency series description, yes, it is very familiar to Ms. Gracie’s fans – it’s almost a direct facsimile of her Merridew Sisters. Recycling much? More like reusing, and she’s done it better before.

To be sure, the Chance “sisters” have some surface differences, beginning with heroine #1, the eldest martyr – no, sorry, sister, governess Abby Chantry. Abigail is tucking her charges into bed when a bedraggled, sketchy chick turns up at her employers’ house with news that her younger sister’s in trouble: Jane has been kidnapped to a brothel, Daisy the sketchbag says, and needs rescuing before it’s Too Late. So Abby goes to the evil Mort’s, plucks Jane, Daisy, and Damaris (another troubled waif) from the clutches of the big bad whoremonger, and they run away to seal the fledgling bonds of sisterhood in visions of happy dressmaking in Bath.

Except, of course, no one can dressmake happily in Bath without money, no matter how talented Daisy’s fingers and willing the other girls are. Normally the new Chance sisters would chug along in acceptable storybook impoverishment, but then Jane gets sick – gasp! – and they need money for a doctor. So Abby rappels out their attic window into the neighbouring house, where she has spied some candlesticks, but bumps into Lady Beatrice Davenham, aforementioned crotchety and sickly old ham. Anyway, Abby charms Lady Bea, and by dint of her angelic goodness inveigles an indeterminate stay chez her ladyship for herself and her sisters.

I might have gotten some minor details wrong – like maybe Abby was going to steal actual money instead of a candlestick, too many shades of Jean Valjean there – but it doesn’t change a wildly improbable premise, nor make it better. And honestly, nor can I be bothered to check for the details. If the accompanying story were amusing, touching, or both, then improbabilities can be dismissed as charms. Since The Autumn Bride is derivative and dull, I do not excuse the premise.

And nor do I forgive the saccharine invasion. Sweetness has always been a trademark of Ms. Gracie’s books, and I’ve found that only half have enough substance to balance the sugar. I’ll reserve judgment on the rest of the series – Jane looks like she has some bite to her, despite appearances of shallow pragmatism – but mostly the book is a diabetic’s nightmare.

So I’ve talked about the characters, the premise, and the prose. What am I missing? Oh right. Max, the hero. Meh.

Which, I suppose, pretty much goes for the whole book.

Buy it at Amazon/iBooks/Barnes and Noble/Kobo

Reviewed by Enya Young

Grade: C

Sensuality: Warm

Review Date: 31/01/13

Publication Date: 2013/02

Review Tags: 

Recent Comments …

  1. excellent book: interesting, funny dialogs, deep understanding of each character, interesting secondary characters, and also sexy.

I live in Seattle, Washington and work as a legal assistant. I remember learning to read (comic strips) at a young age and nowadays try to read about 5-6 books a week. I love to travel, especially to Europe, and enjoy exploring smaller towns off the tourist track though London is my favorite city in the world.

guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments