TEST
I picked up Odd Child Out on a bit of a whim. I’d heard some great things about Ms. MacMillan’s work, the synopsis caught my attention, and looked like something I’d enjoy. Unfortunately, I didn’t do enough research into the author’s work before deciding to review this book, and I ended up more than a little confused by certain plot points that apparently harkened back to the first book in the author’s Jim Clemo series.
Noah Sandler and Abdi Mahad have been best friends for years. The boys come from totally different backgrounds, but the differences in their life circumstances don’t seem to matter to them. Noah is white, upper middle-class and terminally ill, while Abdi’s family immigrated to England from Somalia in order to escape the political unrest there and his family is struggling to make ends meet in a country that hasn’t always been particularly welcoming to them. The friendship appears to be beneficial to both Abdi and Noah, but, when Noah is found floating in a local canal, uncomfortable questions must be asked, even if the answers aren’t what anyone wants to hear.
Detective Jim Clemo has just returned to work after six months mandatory leave. It seems he fell into a deep depression after his last case – and here I have to point out that if I had read the previous book, I’m sure I would have had a much better understanding of Jim’s difficulties, but coming in where I did left me struggling to piece things together. It’s obvious his boss isn’t fully convinced Jim is ready to return to work, so she asks him to look into what she’s sure will turn out to be nothing but a schoolboy prank. He is asked to interview Abdi in an attempt to uncover the truth about Noah’s accident. But Abdi isn’t talking, and Jim soon becomes convinced there’s more at play here than two boys sneaking out on a lark.
Over the next couple of days, Jim does his best to launch a full investigation into what happened to Noah, but his efforts are thwarted more often than not. Noah is in a medically-induced coma, and Abdi seems to be in a state of shock. Discussions with both families yield very little information, and Jim finds himself faced with far more questions than answers. But things suddenly come to a head when Noah succumbs to his injuries and Abdi, fearful of being implicated in the death of his best friend, disappears.
Ms. MacMillan has crafted an emotionally taught thriller that deals with some timely issues. Racial tensions as well as the exploitation of immigrants are explored in some depth, and it’s obvious she did a great deal of research into these matters, as she handles them with sensitivity and grace. However, I sometimes felt the social commentary overwhelmed the mystery, and I grew a little frustrated by what felt like the author’s attempts to hammer her point home too vigorously.
The narrative style of the story might prove difficult for some readers. We see things from multiple perspectives, something I usually enjoy, but I had some trouble following the various shifts in both setting and tense. Jim’s chapters are told in first person, while everyone else narrates in third person. Some characters tell us what is happening in the present while others recount the events leading up to Noah’s death. I sometimes had trouble keeping track of the course of events, especially as no two characters told the exact same story.
The characters are well-drawn, and Ms. MacMillan manages to give each just enough backstory to make them realistic. Jim is the only exception, and my problems with his character are mostly due to my unfamiliarity with the events of his previous case. He’s a very damaged man, and I wanted to understand what made him that way. It’s obvious many of his problems originated in the previous book, and I found myself confused by references to people and events the author didn’t recap here.
So, while I enjoyed Odd Child Out, it wasn’t the overwhelming success I had been hoping for. I imagine people who have read What She Knew, the first installment in the series, might come away with greater satisfaction than I did. Ms. MacMillan is a talented writer, and it’s likely I’ll read more of her work in the future. I’ll just be sure I read things in the proper order next time.
Buy Now: A/BN/iB/K
Grade: B-
Book Type: Mystery
Sensuality: N/A
Review Date: 02/10/17
Publication Date: 10/2017
Recent Comments …
Yep
This sounds delightful! I’m grabbing it, thanks
excellent book: interesting, funny dialogs, deep understanding of each character, interesting secondary characters, and also sexy.
I don’t think anyone expects you to post UK prices – it’s just a shame that such a great sale…
I’m sorry about that. We don’t have any way to post British prices as an American based site.
I have several of her books on my TBR and after reading this am moving them up the pile.