TEST
I frankly don’t know what to say about this book. But, if you’re willing to stay with me here, I’m willing to take a stab at it.
Have you read James Fenimore Cooper’s, The Last of the Mohicans? Voluntarily? Or did you study only parts of it in the tenth grade, as I did? This classic piece of American literature is from a far different era, one we today would not recognize. It was written for a different readership, one without television, movies, radio, often without newspapers or access to many books. An audience where its readers lived in isolation, far apart from neighbors, who had long evenings to fill with some kind of entertaining distraction. Books of this ilk were often meant to be read aloud, before the hearth, for the benefit of the entire family. They were lengthy, flowery in their verbiage, slow-moving in their action, and filled with protracted descriptions intended to decorate the reader/listener’s head with images.
Such, it seems, is Into The Wilderness, and I don’t mean that as an insult. It is on characters introduced in The Last of the Mohicans that Sara Donati has based her ambitious first novel. While most full-length historical romance novels total around 120,000 words (give or take), Into The Wilderness is a whopping 355,000 words (give or take), making it 3-times longer than the average romance you will read this month. So, is this novel a romance at all, or is it more historical fiction with a love story interwoven within? Thus my confusion. Strictly taken as a romance, it fails. As a historical, however, it succeeds rather well. So how does a reviewer evaluate a historical that’s being marketed as a romance?
The premise of the story rests with educated, independent, feisty, purposeful spinster Elizabeth Middleton, who has recently arrived in 1792 New York state, intending to open a school which will offer an education to the settlement’s children of all races – white, black, Indian. While her father and brother want her to marry well-to-do doctor Richard Todd, Elizabeth finds herself attracted to Mohawk-raised Nathaniel Bonner, a white man who’s Mahican (Mohican) wife died several years ago, and who finds Elizabeth a woman worth noting. Nathaniel is handsome, intelligent, sexy, and admires Elizabeth for the very traits for which her own culture has virtually ostracized her. He doesn’t care that English society has placed her on the shelf. To him, she appears to be the kind of woman a man should have by his side.
There is a dispute over the land on which Paradise, the community Elizabeth’s father founded, is built, and the Mahicans want to buy back Hidden Wolf Mountain from Judge Middleton. Determined not to sell, her father tries to persuade Elizabeth to marry Dr. Todd, with ownership of the mountain as her dowry.
Having fallen in love, in defiance of her father, and convention, Elizabeth marries Nathaniel, and the two flee into the wilderness to escape the wrath and hot pursuit of the spurned doctor, who re-e-e-ally wanted that mountain. A (large) cast of well-rounded secondary characters, excellent research and historical details, internal and external conflicts, and genuine love between the hero and heroine, combine to make this a good read. Certainly, author Donati’s efforts are to be applauded – she’s a talented writer and has an agreeable style. Having said that, the intimidating size of this book insinuates itself into any evaluation of it, and I personally found the book far too long to consistently hold my interest. While I can appreciate (and I do!) what it must have taken to construct Into The Wilderness, it is not a book I would have walked into a bookstore and picked up.
Is this novel worth the effort of reading three other books? Depends on what you’re looking for. If you want a true historical in every sense of the word, and can appreciate a view into the America of two centuries past, then, yes, you will love Into The Wilderness, and will be first in line for the sequel. While the relationship between Elizabeth and Nathaniel is appealing, if you’re looking for a straight romance that you can conquer in a few days, you may not find what you’re looking for here.
For the record, among others, I have read Gone With The Wind, War and Peace, and Les Miserables (which came in at about 1500 pages). I am capable of sticking with a storyline that doesn’t wrap up in 120,000 words. But, what I was looking for in those three books, is not what I look for in a romance. The storyline of Into The Wilderness did not compel me the way the characters and events did in those other three novels, so, even if Into The Wilderness had been shorter, my evaluation of it would probably have remained the same.
Buy it at Amazon/Apple Books/Barnes and Noble/Kobo
Grade: B
Book Type: Historical Fiction
Sensuality: Warm
Review Date: 20/08/98
Publication Date: 1999
Recent Comments …
Yep
This sounds delightful! I’m grabbing it, thanks
excellent book: interesting, funny dialogs, deep understanding of each character, interesting secondary characters, and also sexy.
I don’t think anyone expects you to post UK prices – it’s just a shame that such a great sale…
I’m sorry about that. We don’t have any way to post British prices as an American based site.
I have several of her books on my TBR and after reading this am moving them up the pile.
It looks like this review came out around the time the first book was published (wow… it’s been 20 years!). I follow historical fiction just as much as romance, so I’ve always associated it with historical fiction. Even when browsing in bookstores I’ve only ever seen the series shelved with general fiction. The series is six books, and I would classify it as historical family saga, too. By the way, the author pays homage to Gabaldon by making a reference to Claire, Jamie and Ian in this.
Interesting comment on the review. I had never heard of this book (indeed the review is from 1998) and was intrigued enough to look up the book and the series. It sounds like a terrific “Family Saga” type of story. But not what a typical romance reader expects – so I think the review is spot on. If you know what to expect, you will probably love it; if you are expecting a typical romance which usually takes place with a limited time span, you won’t….
Quite frankly Marianne Stillings, I dont know what to say about your review. I found it cold and insensitive and unimaginative. this book gripped me from beginning to end and I cant wait to read the rest of the series! It had EVERYTHING!! Cultural sensitivity, warmth, sensual love, family love, colourful characters, adventure….everything you could possibly want in a good book!! I guess you could class it as a historical romance, but there was SO much more to it than that! Accolades to Sarah Donati I say and many of them!!! Thankyou for a WONDERFUL read….ALL 355,000 words of it!!