Four Men and a Lady

TEST

Remember John Hughes’ 1980s high school movies? Ever wonder what happened to those misfit, working-class girls when they left town, grew up, and looked back on life since high school? Alison Kent’s latest book, Four Men and a Lady, reads as if one of those Hughes heroines got to attend her 15th high school reunion, complete with flashbacks to her fashion-challenged former self.

Heidi Malone was the Joker in “The Deck,” a group of five high school friends (the titular “four men and a lady”). They played jazz and hung out together. For the four guys, it was something fun to do. For Heidi, it was an escape and an anchor she desperately needed as she fought her way out of her squalid home life and sought to escape her small town, wrong-side-of-the-tracks origins. Her bitter awareness of class differences made her unable to see the possibility for more than friendship (an uneasy one at that) with golden boy Ben Tannen, the member of the Deck with all the family money and connections.

This sets the stage for a humdinger of a reunion, as both Ben and Heidi come to town with the agenda of resolving past issues, and quickly realize that they are exploring the possibility of a future. Both have left their teenage selves behind, but both carry serious baggage with them: Ben has his unrequited longing for Heidi, and Heidi has her guilt and shame for hurting Ben terribly on their graduation day, along with her lingering defensiveness about her poor-trash roots.

Whew! That’s a lot of ground to cover in a short category romance, and it sounds awfully heavy as well. Alison Kent’s latest Harlequin Temptation does cover a lot of territory, both with its plot and the depth of emotions it explores. However, Kent also keeps the story light, fast-paced, and humorous: no small achievement when you have a large canvas to work with, and a truly impressive accomplishment in the compressed storytelling of the category format.

Moreover, the author accomplishes this by using lengthy flashbacks to show the key events of four years of high school. We get to see what shaped the characters’ memories and their reaction to the reunion, from the first meeting with awkward, punky Heidi in ninth grade, to the climactic showdown that left Ben (literally) scarred for life. The flashbacks are never distracting; the transitions between past and present are smoothly handled. They add a great deal of emotional dimension to the characters, Heidi in particular.

Ben and Heidi both seem like real people: multi-faceted, successful yet still carrying resentments and shame from the people they were fifteen years before. Like most of us, they made impulsive decisions and mistakes in high school that they cringe to recall now. And when they are together, past or present, their attraction is electric, exciting and believable. The love scene that consummates their relationship is creative and hot, worthy of Harlequin’s promotion of Temptation as the “sexier” line (although why, why do we have to have yet another virgin in her 30s?).

Four Men and a Lady almost has too much story to fit in the shorter series romance format. The detailed exploration of Ben and Heidi, past and present, leaves the other members of the Deck noticeably underdeveloped as characters. Heidi’s pal Quentin has just enough time in view to be really intriguing. The other two members hardly show up at all, particularly in the present-day sections of the book. These characters are crying out for stories of their own, and I hope they get them in future releases, especially Quentin.

Meanwhile, don’t miss Four Men and a Lady. And when you read it, try to picture Molly Ringwald or Ally Sheedy in those flashback scenes, perhaps with an appropriately moody Smiths or Psychedelic Furs song playing in the background.

Reviewed by Colleen McMahon

Grade: A

Sensuality: Hot

Review Date: 05/10/99

Publication Date: 1999/09

Recent Comments …

  1. excellent book: interesting, funny dialogs, deep understanding of each character, interesting secondary characters, and also sexy.

guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments