Desolation Road

TEST

When you read a Christine Feehan book, you know what you’re getting.  No matter the series, no matter the hero, no matter the heroine, you know the formula, and it’s either  one you loathe or one you can’t live without.  But the added wrinkle here – a D/s relationship with full-on kitten play – is something that drags Desolation Road below the line of recommendation.

One can check off the Classic Feehan Tropes as one goes along.  Aleksei ‘Absinthe’ Solokov (check for an unusual nickname) is a big burly dude who’s a part of gang made up of his former childhood friends (check) who were all horrifically abused physically, sexually and emotionally (check) by their kidnappers as part of a sex ring/spy training school, and it is described in intense detail on the page (check) and causes them to have horrible flashbacks that only their lovers can help soothe (check).  Since fleeing their abusers, the Torpedo Ink gang have left the military (check) and then formed an MC where they do less than legal things to make money (Absinthe is somehow a ‘jack of all trades’ lawyer while also participating in said MC. Yeah… just don’t ask questions).  Absinthe is a more sensitive soul because he’s been sneaking away to the local library for peace and quiet lately. Which is where he meets his redheaded heroine – who is also a big reason for his sudden devotion to libraries.

Miss Scarlet Foley is said librarian, and has a peanut-butter-brained internal monologue filled with Oh My Gods (check) and thinks Absinthe is super handsome and thus involves herself in his life without thinking too hard about it. While we are told that Miss Foley is obsessed with books and a master of multiple languages (hint: she rarely speaks any of them in the book, and Absinthe mainly speaks Russian around her), that she has one of the best and brightest brains that Absinthe has ever come across, and she doesn’t remember the title of Sleeping Beauty or the name of the princess who appears in it with full regularity, something that would probably get her drummed out of the librarian’s union (not that she hesitates to resign when Absinthe tells her to.) When we later learn she has training in the sword-based arts thanks to a past involving (checkmark!) an equally physically and sexually abusive suckhole of a childhood, the reader is meanwhile left amazed she’s smart enough to even swing a cane.

Even though the Torpedo Ink gang have a variety of psychic abilities maintained through their group bond, Absinthe is the least fortunate, in that he’s a human sponge for the group’s past pain (check, and hello Carpathians).  Absinthe has chosen not to control Scarlet with his voice – another skill he has – but he’ll have the gang’s hacker run a background check on her – oh, and he stole the fork she ate with during their first date so they can run her prints, because he’s paranoid as is every other member of Torpedo Ink.  The book makes it clear that all of the members are fucked up, and instead of having them fix themselves they wallow in their unhealthy obsessive bonds and allow them to fester. They fuck together, they get drunk together, and they play games together.  This is incredibly creepy, but perhaps would be less so if it were a ménage romance or something.

Every Feehan paranormal adds a new layer of crispy WTF-ery to the uh-okay parfait.  In the Carpathian series, you have Intense!Soulmate!Bonds. In Torpedo Ink, the kink is, well, kink.  Miss Foley becomes Absinthe’s submissive. To Feehan’s credit, they do engage in some forms of negotiation, he practices aftercare, and some people will say ‘fuck reality, give me that juicy porn’, but the sex isn’t that sexy unless you like Feehan’s usual ‘your-little-pussy-is-mine’ style blandishments. Scarlet needs a guy to top her to get off, and that would be fine, if Feehan had handled things in a manner that suggested she actually knows what acts of dominance and submission entail.

Absinthe is a mediocre Dom at first.  He takes care of Scarlet’s limits, and there’s the traditional shaving-of-the-pudenda-to-equal-ownership-exchange (this happens on their wedding day so uh. Yikes.)  But he also keeps a woman shivering and wet alone in a bathtub for hours to prove she will submit to him.  And once she does, in comes the kitten play.

Let me brace our more vanilla readers for what ‘kitten play’ means, since it’s you might not have heard of it before. Scarlet gets off on pretending she’s a cat in the bedroom and Absinthe indulges her. That requires a tail buttplug being tucked up Scarlet’s Hershey highway, licking up dishes of milk, sucking milk off of Absinthian’s dick and drinking his “cream”, keeping her in a cage, putting nipple clamps on her, walking her on a leash and so much purring and clawing of carpets.  While something like this can be sexy in practice, on the page it is gooftacular.  It knows the words of the Dom and the sub but not the music; it’s all written so hootily, and anyone who isn’t into this very specific sort of petplay kink (which is NOT hinted about on the book’s back cover blurb) is likely to be bored or embarrassed. By the time Scarlet has to literally fellate Absinthe back to reality, I was ready to tap out.

You usually know what you’re getting these days when you pick up a Christine Feehan book, but the whole kink thing is a fresh dimension.  Too bad it doesn’t help the book.  Desolation Road works best as a scratching post.

Buy it at: Amazon, Audible, or your local independent bookstore

Visit our Amazon Storefront

Reviewed by Lisa Fernandes

Grade: D

Book Type: Paranormal Romance

Sensuality: Burning

Review Date: 18/08/20

Publication Date: 07/2020

Recent Comments …

  1. excellent book: interesting, funny dialogs, deep understanding of each character, interesting secondary characters, and also sexy.

Lisa Fernandes is a writer, reviewer and recapper who lives somewhere on the East Coast. Formerly employed by Firefox.org and Next Projection, she also currently contributes to Women Write About Comics. Read her blog at http://thatbouviergirl.blogspot.com/, follow her on Twitter at http://twitter.com/thatbouviergirl or contribute to her Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/MissyvsEvilDead or her Ko-Fi at ko-fi.com/missmelbouvier

guest

70 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sonia
Sonia
Guest
08/19/2020 7:21 am

I gave up on this author. Some books were great for me, others more meh but I gave up when the awful way women are treated stopped being a cause or consequence of the plot/story line and became almost a requirement for each book.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Sonia
08/19/2020 1:56 pm

It’s kind of competing with her fetish for manpain and angst at this point.

Lieselotte
Lieselotte
Guest
08/19/2020 4:37 am

Wonderful review, thank you, Lisa!
 
You really hit all the spots for someone who, a long long time ago, was a fan of Feehan – you described all the tender spots she started hurting more and more of over her career, perfectly
 
… I remember loving the first few books she wrote, the Carpathian idea worked for me, at the time – I think at around book 5 or so it stopped being good. They were repetitive, but for a while, predictable formula romances to enjoy when in the mood. Lots of skimming though, over time.
 
Then, the whole “Game” series came and was doubtful for me, just too much of a cruel environment, I could not believe that these people could ever have a content life, being so damaged, and constantly being re-damaged by the villain(s) in each next book.
 
So, I then tried a book by her every 5 years or so, just to know what she does.
 
By the “Shadow” series I was at the point of actually returning a book by her, because I felt that paying for this abusive hero and the heroine accepting this as love was too much.
 
Now, I see that it can actually get worse….
 

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Lieselotte
08/19/2020 1:55 pm

I used to love Feehan’s vampire romances back in her early publishing days, and you’re right – the Carpathians started well enough but have devolved into her pattern of obsessive lovers/creepy soulbonds/mental manip of the heroines involved, at which point I couldn’t stand reading them anymore (the last one I read soulbonded an underage character to an adult, yikes). The last one really padded things out with a bunch of stuff glossaries and the like.

Elaine S
Elaine S
Guest
08/19/2020 1:39 am

Well, Lisa, I read your review to my adorable cat just now, while we shared a bowl of cream. She laughed and said you write a purrfect review but she will be giving this one a wide berth. She said 5 minutes in her litter tray after eating a dead mouse and a having a satisfying shredding of the sofa is far more satisfying. Meow!!

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Elaine S
08/19/2020 1:06 pm

Give her plenty of catnip for me!

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
08/18/2020 5:26 pm

Quick comment to point out that Lynn reviewed the first volume of this series and it absolutely did not contain petplay, and didn’t seem to include kink either?:

https://allaboutromance.com/book-review/judgment-road-by-christine-feehan/

MickeyD
MickeyD
Guest
Reply to  Lisa Fernandes
08/18/2020 11:26 pm

It’s been awhile but to the best of my recollection, Judgement Road and the next book in the series would have been classified as hot. Alpha males in the bedroom but not really over the kink line. The prior book to this one unfortunately crossed the line and had the same issues, except instead of the kitten play it was public sex. Quite frankly both should be classified as erotica. Both because of length and content of the scenes. Also both are seriously lacking in an external plot. Since I’ve been following the spinoffs since the Drake Sisters and can get it from the library, I will probably read the next. But she is going to use this series as a reason to write erotica, I’ll pass.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  MickeyD
08/19/2020 1:03 pm

Yeah, this volume strongly hints that they have their public sex secret treehouse and that if Scarlet wants to marry Absinthe she has to be Down with and that they all share one another but if she doesn’t want to share herself she can just perch on her cat tuffett and, I don’t know, lick her “paws” (I’m still amused that they had this elaborate collaring stuff but he didn’t buy her a hood or something, like most petplay people have). But we don’t spend any time there, it’s just talked about. This one is actually weirdly plotty RE Scarlet wanting to kill her abuser instead, and a lot of Absinthe angsting and having flashbacks and her having conflicts with other people in the TI family. I’m amused at how squeamish it is about menage while having its collared heroine lick milk off of the hero’s dick.

Nan De Plume
Nan De Plume
Guest
Reply to  Lisa Fernandes
08/19/2020 1:18 pm

I’m amused at how squeamish it is about menage while having its collared heroine lick milk off of the hero’s dick.” I’m going to guess the squeamishness comes from its “romance” designation where- traditionally- the hero and heroine are the only characters allowed to have on-page sex.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Nan De Plume
08/23/2020 12:57 pm

Apparently there was group sex in the previous volume, so I have to wonder.

Caroline Russomanno
Caroline Russomanno
Member
08/18/2020 11:53 am

I was partway through this review and hit “crispy WTF-ery to the uh-okay parfait” and I thought “This has to be Lisa.” I love your review voice! Great job!

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Caroline Russomanno
08/18/2020 2:53 pm

Muaha! My reputation precedes me. Thank you!

Chrisreader
Chrisreader
Guest
08/18/2020 11:51 am

And to think I let my library loan of this book run out after reading a few pages because it seemed generic and boring, lol. Can’t say I’m sorry about that after reading this review.

I’m constantly amazed at all the very specific “play” there is in books (and apparently in the world now). I’m reading one now where “praise” is a thing. It’s pretty benign and I’d be more in favor of it except the hero keeps telling the heroine “good girl” in the bedroom. There’s no Daddy talk or anything like that (thank heavens as that’s a deal breaker for me), but I just wish he’d say “You’re an amazing woman” or ‘you’re so great” or something else besides “good girl” over and over.

Thank you Lisa for reading this, your review and suffering through it so we don’t have to!

Thanks to this book I’m really going to have to hesitate before referring to myself as a “cat person” again. Yikes.

Nan De Plume
Nan De Plume
Guest
Reply to  Chrisreader
08/18/2020 12:50 pm

I’m constantly amazed at all the very specific “play” there is in books (and apparently in the world now).”

Are you referring to romance books or erotica? Because if you’ve been reading erotica, I have some insight into this. Vanilla erotica as in man meets woman, they have a coffee, flirt, and end up at one of the lead’s apartment to do the deed sells very poorly overall if the comments over at Reddit are any indication (plus my own limited research). Erotica authors who want to take their stories beyond a mere hobby have to target niches or kinks in order to sell significant numbers. Some of this might be spilling over into romance reading as well.

I remember an interesting conversation between Joe Rogan and Bill Maher about how they couldn’t get over how extreme pornography has gotten. They fondly remembered the days when it was naughty enough to just watch two people having sex instead of having to up the ante with kink, spitting, slapping, choking, and pseudo-incest among other acts pornography consumers generally didn’t expect in the 1970s-1980s. (Sure, the outlying stuff always existed, but Maher made a good point that the internet allows people with very specific fetishes to find each other and form a community- perhaps too easily, he mused.)

I’m reading one now where ‘praise’ is a thing. It’s pretty benign and I’d be more in favor of it except the hero keeps telling the heroine “good girl” in the bedroom…I just wish he’d say “You’re an amazing woman” or ‘you’re so great” or something else besides “good girl” over and over.” That’s good to know. I think erotica authors can get in a rut sometimes too just based on what’s selling. It’s kind of like Duke stories in romance begat more Duke stories, and romance writers keep writing them because that’s what’s selling instead of trying something new. I might have to throw some more “You’re so great” and “You’re amazing” lines in my work. :)

And just for the record, “Daddy” talk is a nope for me too.

Chrisreader
Chrisreader
Guest
Reply to  Nan De Plume
08/18/2020 3:45 pm

You know I didn’t even know what I was reading was technically classified as so I checked. It’s Sci fi alien romance. Yup I’ve gone down the rabbit hole during this pandemic. But technically it’s not erotica and it’s got a pretty involved story and some world building as well.

I have no problems with praise kink or whatever it’s called. I’m all for more praise in general, in life, and the hero saying nice things to the heroine is always very welcome in any romance I read- and vice versa. It’s just the parental sounding nature of the “good girl” praise over and over raised my hackles a bit.

It might just be me, but I don’t think so as the author had to post on her Facebook page there was absolutely no “Daddy” stuff involved to concerned potential readers. I don’t like to pooh pooh other people’s likes but anything vaguely parental is a hard no for me.

I do think romance has become far more explicit over the years. This is not a complaint, just an observation and I think the lines between what is “too hot’ for romance have been almost completely erased.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Chrisreader
08/18/2020 2:51 pm

Hah! Like I said – the petplay element kind of runs the reader over like a Mack Truck in the first fourth of the book. It’s not hinted at on the back cover (just “secrets,” which envelops everything from her plan to SPOILERS – kill the guy who abused her and her childhood trauma and his psychic bond with the others as well as his OWN childhood trauma – but the kitten kink takes up a LOT of page space here)

Oh yeah, praise kink is definitely a thing!

Hah! Just tell them you’re a Nastassja Kinski fan!

Chrisreader
Chrisreader
Guest
Reply to  Lisa Fernandes
08/18/2020 3:50 pm

Well I have found my line in the sand. I’ve read Joanna Wylde MC books that cover child abuse, revenge murder plots etc but that kitty stuff is just a hard nope.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Chrisreader
08/18/2020 3:57 pm

Yep. Not my kink at all either!

Susan/DC
Susan/DC
Guest
Reply to  Chrisreader
08/18/2020 5:58 pm

“Good girl” sounds like what you say when training a dog, which may be a thing but it’s not my thing.

Nan De Plume
Nan De Plume
Guest
08/18/2020 11:18 am

Thanks for the review, Lisa.

It’s interesting to note that a lot of reviewers on Amazon are squicked out by this Feehan title. There are a lot of comments to the tune of This is supposed to be romance, but Feehan keeps upping the ante with kinkier scenes. If she were self-published, I have no doubt Amazon would classify her work as “erotica.” Incidentally, quite a few self-published romance authors have complained on the eroticauthors Reddit forum that their books are being thrown into the erotica category (which cuts off certain advertising opportunities) just for having sex scenes, and I can almost guarantee their stuff doesn’t hit Feehan’s level of kink. There’s definitely a double standard when it comes to what traditionally published and self-published writers can get away with.

“But he also keeps a woman shivering and wet alone in a bathtub for hours to prove she will submit to him.” Definitely not sexy, and quite possibly hazardous.

Just as a side musing, can anybody imagine what would have happened if Harlequin Dare authors were allowed to take things this far?

Chrisreader
Chrisreader
Guest
Reply to  Nan De Plume
08/18/2020 11:56 am

I agree, Feehan is getting a lot of leeway because she’s a big name. As I said in my comment I let my loan lapse without reading it because it just seemed super generic! I’m pretty shocked this is a big publishers book and not a kindle unlimited offering.

DiscoDollyDeb
DiscoDollyDeb
Guest
Reply to  Nan De Plume
08/18/2020 12:23 pm

@Nan: I don’t think the Dare line would address “kitten play,” but I must admit I was surprised at the intensity of the bdsm play in Caitlin Crews’s most recent Dare trilogy: TAKE ME, TEACH ME, TEMPT ME—particularly TEMPT ME which includes one very long “scene” that comprises at least 1/3 of the book (and includes nipple clamps, among other things). I think Dare is finally finding its footing as, basically, “hot, but not too far out there.” Another thing I found interesting about TEMPT ME was its acknowledgment that for young women in their early-to-mid-twenties today, 50 SHADES OF GREY has been a fact of their cultural landscape, if not their sex lives, since their teens. I also loved that the Dom hero of TEMPT ME threw some shade at 50 SHADES!

Nan De Plume
Nan De Plume
Guest
Reply to  DiscoDollyDeb
08/18/2020 12:31 pm

I think Dare is finally finding its footing as, basically, ‘hot, but not too far out there.'” It sounds like it. Unfortunately, I think they are going to discontinue the line, if their Submittable page is any indication.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Nan De Plume
08/18/2020 2:45 pm

Yep, they announced it’s going this past winter.

DiscoDollyDeb
DiscoDollyDeb
Guest
Reply to  Lisa Fernandes
08/18/2020 3:35 pm

So, Harlequin discontinued the really good (and hot) Blaze line only to replace it with the Dare line which struggled for several years trying to determine exactly what it was going to be only to discontinue the line just when it appears that (some of their authors at least) were finding the right template for their books? I’m guessing that the first couple of years of Dare books were so wobbly the line didn’t acquire the loyal “I’ll read anything this line publishes” audience that something like Harlequin Presents has. Please don’t tell me HP is for the chop…there’s only so much misery 2020 can hand me.

Nan De Plume
Nan De Plume
Guest
Reply to  DiscoDollyDeb
08/18/2020 4:44 pm

“Please don’t tell me HP is for the chop…”

I don’t think you have to worry. I just checked http://harlequin.submittable.com, and they are still accepting submissions for the Harlequin Presents line. Plus the fact they release 8 new titles per month and have a long history with a winning formula makes me pretty confident about their future. (I’ve never read one myself, but from what I’ve heard, they’re not going anywhere.) My one concern is if they got the ax because somebody thought the line is too controversial for the 21st century with all its over-the-top dashing, possessive foreigners and all. But they’d really be shooting themselves in the foot if that were the case.

Plus, Harlequin Inspired Historicals are taking submissions again after a hiatus. I know a lot of readers missed the clean, wholesome HR line. (Not me!) So they know what’s tried and true.

Nan De Plume
Nan De Plume
Guest
Reply to  Lisa Fernandes
08/18/2020 3:49 pm

Do you remember where you saw the official announcement? I didn’t read anything on So You Think You Can Write or Harlequin Blog. I just noticed their Submittable page doesn’t have the Dare category anymore.

Also, Harlequin was all pumped up for two limited edition Inspired lines: Cold Case and Mountain Rescue. Those submission categories are gone too (after a very short time), but I haven’t heard any news if they scrapped the project entirely or if they will be releasing some of those titles next year. They seemed like odd categories to begin with. I mean, Mountain Rescue and Cold Case sound like really awesome limited edition lines, but making them both Inspirationals? Dude, they missed on a big opportunity for some steamy mountain rescues. You know, with the forced proximity aspect and all, body-to-body warming and the whole bit. I’m not sure who on their staff thought Inspirational was a great direction for these two lines.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Nan De Plume
08/18/2020 4:01 pm

https://www.harlequin.com/shop/brand/harlequin-dare.html Looks like I stand corrected; they seem to be publishing new books through September at least.

Chrisreader
Chrisreader
Guest
Reply to  DiscoDollyDeb
08/18/2020 3:54 pm

I think 50 Shades had an impact in the same way Sex And The City did on young women and people in general. I think SATC’s was greater across the board but they both expanded the rules on what was acceptable to do and what was acceptable to talk about.

DiscoDollyDeb
DiscoDollyDeb
Guest
Reply to  Chrisreader
08/18/2020 4:24 pm

Yes—50 SHADES being the Gen Z/Millennial SATC is good comparison. I’m very much a Boomer and I remember things like Nancy Friday’s MY SECRET GARDEN, Anais Nin’s THE DELTA OF VENUS, and Anne Rice’s earliest “Sleeping Beauty” erotica (which she originally published under a pseudonym) being eye-openers for my generation. Of course, we didn’t have the internet to spread the knowledge far and wide—just shoving a book into a friend’s hands and saying, “Girl, you gotta read this!” Such an innocent time. Incidentally, my two youngest daughters (22 year-old twins) love SATC and have binge-watched it during quarantine—they view the show as a time capsule, I suppose.

Susan/DC
Susan/DC
Guest
Reply to  DiscoDollyDeb
08/18/2020 5:49 pm

And don’t forget Erica Jong’s Fear of Flying, which was another eye-opening book about women and sex. I was definitely a lot less innocent after I read it than I’d been before.

DiscoDollyDeb
DiscoDollyDeb
Guest
Reply to  Susan/DC
08/18/2020 6:42 pm

Yes indeed. In was in my mid-teens and it seems the timeline was MY SECRET GARDEN (1972), FEAR OF FLYING (1973), and SWEET SAVAGE LOVE (1974). The floodgates were open…and we would never be the same again!

Dabney Grinnan
Dabney Grinnan
Admin
Reply to  DiscoDollyDeb
08/18/2020 7:15 pm

For me, it would be:

Ann Head’s Mr. and Mrs. Bo Jo Jones
Judy Blume’s Forever
Rosemary Rogers’ Sweet Savage Love
Judith Krantz’ Scruples

Chrisreader
Chrisreader
Guest
Reply to  Dabney Grinnan
08/18/2020 8:16 pm

Judy Blume’s Forever was passed around secretly by the girls in the upper grades at my school as well as Flowers In The Attic back when I was in about 6th grade I think. I was considered “too young” to read them back then. I think I finally read Forever many years later just to see what the fuss was but I never had any interest in V.C. Andrews.

Dabney Grinnan
Dabney Grinnan
Admin
Reply to  Susan/DC
08/18/2020 7:12 pm

I don’t think that was as widely read but cultural critics were–and are–obsessed with it. I didn’t read it until just a few years ago.

Caz Owens
Caz Owens
Editor
Reply to  Nan De Plume
08/18/2020 12:25 pm

It’s not just Amazon – or rather the book side of Amazon – I was listening to an m/m romance recently and was surprised to see it listed as “erotica” at Audible, which it most definitely wasn’t. Audible’s categorisations are all over the place and it’s not even consistent. Similar books by the same author – even books in the SAME SERIES can end up in different categories.

Nan De Plume
Nan De Plume
Guest
Reply to  Caz Owens
08/18/2020 12:35 pm

Right. Technically we’re allowed to classify our own work on KDP, which can lead to wonky categorization. More specifically, it’s not uncommon for an author to label something as a “Western” because there is less competition in the category, even if “Contemporary Romance” would make more sense. It’s often a case of, “Well, the guy wears cowboy boots in one scene and it takes place in Montana, so I’ll call it a Western to shrink the competition pool.”

But then KDP/Amazon’s algorithms come in and can make further screwy changes, such as romances being classified as erotica.

Chrisreader
Chrisreader
Guest
Reply to  Nan De Plume
08/18/2020 3:51 pm

I always learn so much about the Indy publisher aspect of the market when I read your posts. It explains a lot.

Nan De Plume
Nan De Plume
Guest
Reply to  Chrisreader
08/18/2020 4:24 pm

You’re welcome.

As an added note, I forgot to mention that authors on KDP are allowed to choose two categories per publication (choosing at least one is mandatory for classification purposes), which can also lead to confusion. Many of those categories can be further broken down into subdivisions such as erotica > humorous or romance > Regency. Plus, Amazon sometimes automatically adds designations based on length algorithms that authors can’t access independently such as “Two-Hour Read” or “45-Minute Science Fiction.” Hope this helps clarify some things!

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Nan De Plume
08/18/2020 2:43 pm

There are so many horrified reviews on Goodreads but it’s still maintaining a 4.1 as of a few seconds ago. It’s not a big deal to me because I read mainline erotica and have Life Experience but people coming to this book from anywhere else in her oeuvre are going to be shocked.

I can think of several Dare authors who’d do a better job with this material. Feehan used to write such good historicals but I think at this point – with her being so many books into the Carpathian universe – she’s running out of ways to excite her reader base.

Nan De Plume
Nan De Plume
Guest
Reply to  Lisa Fernandes
08/18/2020 4:28 pm

Yes to all of this. I do think romance writers should be clear if their work goes way beyond typical romance conventions as a courtesy to readers. Granted, the traditionally published generally have no say over blurbs, but at least the publisher should give a heads-up. They ought to know there probably isn’t much crossover between your average Barbara Cartland/Regency fan and kinky kitty play readers. Not saying you can’t like both, but be prepared to alienate a lot of readers if you aren’t upfront about it.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Nan De Plume
08/19/2020 12:58 pm

I’m honestly amazed that her editors let her get away with animal tail buttplugs in a main line romance novel. On one way, how liberating. In another, there are going to be so many people who, even if they were trained on 50 Shade of Grey or whatever, will not be into this unless they kink to a certain kind of D/s.

Nan De Plume
Nan De Plume
Guest
Reply to  Lisa Fernandes
08/19/2020 1:15 pm

I agree with everything you just wrote, Lisa. (And your review was fun!)

I’m also starting to wonder if Feehan actually wants to be an erotica writer but her publishing house has her slapped into the “romance” category. It’s definitely not unheard of for authors’ genres to be limited by what publishers think their branding should look like.

“Desolation Road” definitely sounds like an erotica on the basis of a character making a sexual journey/sexual discoveries about herself as a main focus. If it has an HEA or HFN, which I assume it does given its romance classification, it could possibly be an erotic romance- but I’m not seeing much of the romance aspect based on your review.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Nan De Plume
08/23/2020 12:55 pm

Thank you!

Usually Feehan’s better at the romantic components in her stories, usually.

It is HEA, since they are stuck in Soulmateton, and thus must be with one another or TRAGIC ANGST.

Caz Owens
Caz Owens
Editor
08/18/2020 10:31 am

As all cat owners (or, should I say, humans that cats agree to tolerate and live with) know, they do exactly as they want when and how they want. A submissive feline does not compute!

Chrisreader
Chrisreader
Guest
Reply to  Caz Owens
08/18/2020 11:57 am

Exactly, if the cat had been the Dom that would have made a lot more sense! Lol.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Caz Owens
08/18/2020 2:43 pm

Hah! As I said in the review – she knows the words, not the music.

Star
Star
Guest
Reply to  Caz Owens
08/19/2020 7:48 am

Exactly this! I read this review with a six-month-old kitten purring in my lap (she is now trying to “help” me type this comment), thinking “This is a kink for people who have never actually met a cat.” My cats are super sweet, but they still have one GOAL IN LIAqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq [damnit she hit caps lock and “q” and then turned on musicq – last “q” courtesy of the other cat] one goal in life and that is murdering everything in sight.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Star
08/19/2020 12:39 pm

Hah! Well, to be fair to Scarlet, she does get to kill a guy.

DiscoDollyDeb
DiscoDollyDeb
Guest
08/18/2020 8:42 am

So…like “pony play” only with kittens?

Great review, but I’ll be skipping this book…this series…most likely this author…going forward.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  DiscoDollyDeb
08/18/2020 2:17 pm

Yep, it’s like pony play (pony play is even referenced during the course of this book, and one of the Triggering Incidents for Absinthe involved a pony play training session gone wrong which led to an old friend being murdered). People also like to pretend to be dogs in this subform of D/s play. Definitely not my kink.

DiscoDollyDeb
DiscoDollyDeb
Guest
Reply to  Lisa Fernandes
08/18/2020 3:38 pm

And here I was thinking “Trump pardons Susan B. Anthony” would be the most inexplicable sentence I would read today—and then “a pony play training session gone wrong which led to an old friend being murdered” shows up and smashes all my expectations.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  DiscoDollyDeb
08/18/2020 4:03 pm

It’s just That Kinda Book!

Susan/DC
Susan/DC
Guest
Reply to  DiscoDollyDeb
08/18/2020 6:01 pm

There’s a humor piece by Andy Borowitz in The New Yorker where he has Susan B. Anthony asking Trump not to pardon her because she doesn’t want to wind up on the same Wikipedia page as Roger Stone.

Dabney Grinnan
Dabney Grinnan
Admin
08/18/2020 7:09 am

Kitten play, huh? I’ll add that to the long list of things I’m happy for other consensual adults to do but squicks me personally out. To be fair, I also feel this way about eating green peppers….

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Dabney Grinnan
08/18/2020 2:14 pm

It’s a ykinmkato thing for me too, but still not the most out-there sexual practice I’ve heard of nor experienced nor witnessed. But whew, Feehan does NOT warn you it’s going to happen, and the way she writes it is so painfully silly.

Wendy F
Wendy F
Guest
08/18/2020 6:43 am

I had a good giggle reading this review in bed this morning – until I got to the bit about ‘kitten play’!

Oh well, you learn something new every day.

I can’t for the life of me think how nipple clamps got included as cat-related behaviour though……………….. Surely nobody is stupid enough to try and put them on their cats?

Marian Perera
Marian Perera
Guest
Reply to  Wendy F
08/18/2020 7:08 am

And what about other aspects of cat life, like using a litterbox? Maybe there’s one inside the heroine’s cage?

Dabney Grinnan
Dabney Grinnan
Admin
Reply to  Marian Perera
08/18/2020 7:11 am

I had my husband read this review and he laughed so hard he is still wiping his eyes. Well done, Lisa. Well done.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Dabney Grinnan
08/18/2020 2:13 pm

Was it the Hershey Highway line? I’m still proud of that one.

Wendy F
Wendy F
Guest
Reply to  Marian Perera
08/18/2020 7:17 am

She’s got the buttplug so she doesn’t need one?!

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Wendy F
08/18/2020 2:13 pm

I JUST SCREECHED OUT LOUD.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Marian Perera
08/18/2020 2:09 pm

She actually does claw at things/walk on all fours/perch upon tuffets. Amazingly, he does not buy her a ball to chase or a laser pointer, nor is the idea of a litter box discussed. To my relief.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Wendy F
08/18/2020 2:06 pm

I think it’s just supposed to be a part of the naughty bondagy picture. Like I said, Feehan knows the words but not the music of D/s.

I should have added/mentioned that he literally has bought her a tuffet upon which she perches. Like a cat. And he promises to bring said tuffet to the group’s sex club, where she will perch as a sort of safe place where no one can touch her. Like a cat.

Dabney Grinnan
Dabney Grinnan
Admin
Reply to  Lisa Fernandes
08/18/2020 3:36 pm

Honestly, cats are far cooler than this.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Dabney Grinnan
08/18/2020 4:03 pm

She should at least be scratching more people than she does during the course of the book.

Marian Perera
Marian Perera
Guest
08/18/2020 1:28 am

I would never in my life have associated kittens with nipple clamps or walking on a leash.

Thank you, Lisa and AAR. I am enlightened.

Chrisreader
Chrisreader
Guest
Reply to  Marian Perera
08/18/2020 11:52 am

Co-signing your entire comment.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  Marian Perera
08/18/2020 2:04 pm

Hah, the leash part ALMOST makes sense (some people do walk their cats on leashes). I don’t get why Feehan added nipple clamps and body oils that change temperature when placed on the human skin to the mix, but she did. I feel like she binged a lot of Anne Rice erotica before she started this series.