Band of Sisters

TEST

I love heroines who display spirit, backbone and intelligence with ease and elegance. We’re given several such extraordinary women in Lauren Willig’s Band of Sisters and I found myself completely enthralled by the story as a result.

Kate Moran had attended Smith College, the women’s university favored by some of America’s wealthiest families, on a scholarship. She thought she was fully accepted into her classmate’s  social circle, especially by best friend Emmaline (Emmie)  Van Alden, but during a graduation celebration she overhears a disparaging remark made by Emmie’s cousin, and is angered and embarrassed enough to determine to never again have anything to do with the Smith ladies.

Kate becomes a French teacher at an elite private school and while she’s not exactly happy in the job, she is pleased it enables her to be independent from a difficult family situation. Emmie writes to her over the years but Kate never responds. Her sense that the wealthy socialites of Smith, especially Emmie, see her as nothing more than a charity case who is far from their equal stings her pride and she sees no reason to continue any relationship where she’s seen as somehow ‘less’. Emmie is persistent however, especially when it comes to having Kate join the new Smith College Relief Unit, a group of alumni who plan to enter war-torn towns and villages in France where the German invaders have recently vacated the field in order to aid the French in their rebuilding efforts. Kate, fluent in French and a licensed driver to boot, would be a huge asset to the team. Kate’s initial reluctance slowly erodes under Emmie’s cheerful, relentless begging and she soon finds herself joining Emmie and a host of other “Smithies” as they set sail for France.

It’s a harrowing journey, with the ladies having to sleep on the deck – often in less than ideal conditions – with the threat of being torpedoed constantly hovering over them. Once they arrive in Paris, matters don’t improve. The hotel where they planned to stay doesn’t have enough rooms for them, their supplies are nowhere to be found, the truck Kate is meant to drive arrived in a box and has to be built by their team… the list of setbacks is endless.  While Kate, Emmie and many of the other girls determine to persevere, a shrewish debutante named Maude tries to derail their goal of reaching outlying villages in desperate need of reconstruction in favor of serving donuts and coffee to American soldiers at a Parisian canteen.  Once that mutiny is successfully quelled, they head to the countryside only to find that the chateau that was to be their headquarters has been all but demolished, and the local citizenry, made up primarily of women and children, are living in damp cellars. Their crops, plows, planting supplies, homes, clothes, schools, wells – all were destroyed by the Germans as they retreated.

With their supplies in disarray and no decent place in which to make a base, everyone – the locals, the French government, the allied armies – expects the wealthy do-gooders to go home. Or at least back to Paris. Emmie, Kate and company prove wise, resilient and tenacious,  however. They persevere against tremendous odds, bringing some much needed aid to devastated communities – and building lasting bonds that transcend mere friendship, binding them into a band of sisters.

This is billed as a historical novel rather than women’s fiction and I would agree with that label. The story takes a deep dive into what happened to the real Smith College Relief Unit, covering not just their day-to-day tasks of reconstruction but the harrowing moments of German bombing, a run in with deserters that nearly results in rape, battling snow and the horrific mud of the region in their efforts to get food, medicine and school supplies to the villagers, outrunning advancing enemy troops – their adventures are legion. We also hear of the more mundane difficulties – the endless hunt for supplies, not being able to take a bath, finding themselves hosting allied soldiers, truck breakdowns, livestock that doesn’t cooperate, Maude’s incessant schemes to get them back to Paris… pretty much anything that can go wrong does go wrong. A lot of the narrative emphasis is on the historic events  and the author does an incredible job of making the experiences of our heroines vivid and vibrant and grittily realistic.

The emotional aspect seems almost secondary to the story. It is there, though and it adds a nice psychological tension to the tale. Kate, Emmie, and Emmie’s cousin Julia are our primary heroines and there is some bitter history between them; the remark which had so irritated  Kate at the graduation celebration  had been made by Julia. She starts the tale as the villain, a snobby rich girl determined to keep the Brooklyn scholarship girl, Kate, in her place. But we slowly come to realize there is a lot more going on beneath the surface, and the full story is far more interesting than we had initially been led to believe. Additionally, there are so many miscommunications between Emmie and Kate that their friendship is in constant danger of implosion. It takes much of the book for them to reach a resolution that allows both to realize how important their relationship is to each of them.

Naturally, all three of our protagonists grow and learn throughout this ordeal. Kate slowly comes to acknowledge that while not everyone will judge her strictly on her own merits, most people actually do place more stock on what she accomplishes than they do on where she comes from. That resolution helps her to see her family situation in a new light and to value the women around her who may come from a different class but have the same devotion to hard work and charity that she does. Julia sees standing on her own feet and trusting no one as being her sole shot at surviving the difficult situation she finds herself in, but she learns the merit of trust and friendship as the story progresses. And Emmie – Emmie has no self-worth. Various members of her family have told her she’s not attractive, that she’s flighty and incompetent and incapable of pretty much anything. None of that is true and being in France, accomplishing all that she does and meeting her very own hero helps her to gain confidence.

Emmie’s is the only romance we get in the book and while it is utterly, completely, delightfully charming it is – sadly – brief. If I were to add up all the pages when Emmie and  her hero are together I doubt it would make for 10% of this rather long book, which is a shame because the two of them are a fantastic couple – their shared humor, inside jokes, silly asides and warm conversations always brought a smile to my face.

The book’s only (minor!) flaw is that it is long and the plentiful minutiae can at moments be rather tedious.

That said, Band of Sisters is a richly detailed historical novel which gives a uniquely feminine  perspective to WWI history. I would recommend it to anyone looking for a good read about strong, amazing women overcoming adverse circumstances.

You can read our other review of this title HERE.

Buy it at: Amazon, Audible, or your local independent retailer

Visit our Amazon Storefront

Reviewed by Maggie Boyd

Grade: B+

Book Type: Historical Fiction

Sensuality: Kisses

Review Date: 02/03/21

Publication Date: 03/2021

Review Tags: France World War I

Recent Comments …

  1. excellent book: interesting, funny dialogs, deep understanding of each character, interesting secondary characters, and also sexy.

I've been an avid reader since 2nd grade and discovered romance when my cousin lent me Lord of La Pampa by Kay Thorpe in 7th grade. I currently read approximately 150 books a year, comprised of a mix of Young Adult, romance, mystery, women's fiction, and science fiction/fantasy.

guest

10 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
LeeB.
LeeB.
Guest
03/06/2021 12:03 pm

This was a hard book to put down because it was so good. I really didn’t mind the minutiae or length at all. It made the story even more real. I know Ms. Willig is HUGE on research and it always shows. I never knew about the Smith College sisters so it makes the book even more wonderful. Highly recommended.

Dabney Grinnan
Dabney Grinnan
Admin
Reply to  LeeB.
03/06/2021 1:11 pm

I just gave it to my mom who graduated from a women’s college. I can’t wait to read it!

Maggie Boyd
Maggie Boyd
Guest
Reply to  LeeB.
03/07/2021 8:26 am

I’m glad you loved it. Willig is a fantastic writer whose work always impresses me with how rich and detailed the research is. I don’t know much about WWI so she could have written almost anything and surprised me but I was delighted with her uniquely feminen look at war history. Most battle stories come only from the men in the trenches but this tale really captured the unique perspective of the women and children those battles affect. After finishing this I understood why everyone in Europe was anxious to avoid a second world war. I only had to read 500 pages of war history details and after finishing I was anxious to avoid war, too :-)

Cathy
Cathy
Guest
03/03/2021 7:18 pm

Oh. I love this review!! I get frustrated at romance masquerading as historical fiction and this sounds like straight historical fiction!! I’m excited!

Maggie Boyd
Maggie Boyd
Guest
Reply to  Cathy
03/04/2021 12:44 pm

There is a romance in it but yes, this is historical fiction told from a uniquely feminen perspective.

Susan/DC
Susan/DC
Guest
03/02/2021 7:58 pm

So, and this may be a spoiler so I’ll understand if you put it in spoiler mode:

Spoiler title
but is Emmie’s romance brief because there’s so much going on and it’s only a small part of the book or because her hero dies in the war?
Last edited 3 years ago by Dabney Grinnan
Maggie Boyd
Maggie Boyd
Guest
Reply to  Susan/DC
03/04/2021 11:07 am
Spoiler
Because there is so much going on

Maggie Boyd
Maggie Boyd
Guest
Reply to  Maggie Boyd
03/04/2021 12:43 pm
Bigger Spoiler with more detail
Their wedding is one of the last scenes in the book.

Lieselotte
Lieselotte
Guest
03/02/2021 4:54 am

I really like these side by side reviews with a different emphasis.
They are of course somewhat similar, but the focus is different and I enjoy that a lot!
Thank you for that, both reviewers, and AAR for doing that!

Maggie Boyd
Maggie Boyd
Guest
Reply to  Lieselotte
03/02/2021 10:23 am

Thanks! I’m so glad you like the dual reviews. I like looking at multiple opinions before investing in something, too – especially if my “investment” is going to exceed $10.00. dollars :-) Shannon and I have similar tastes, so it doesn’t surprise me we both enjoyed the book. Hopefully you will, too.