An Unconventional Heiress

TEST

Circa 1810, Sydney society is in transition. The new governor Lachlan Macquarie is raising the status of freed convicts (‘emancipists’), much to the wrath of exclusives who arrived from the United Kingdom freely and, often, temporarily. Sarah Langley, wealthy gentlewoman newly arrived in the city is clearly an exclusive. So how could she possibly be interested in an ex-con emancipist like Dr. Alan Kerr? An Australia-set historical that truly transports (if you’ll pardon the convict-linked expression!) the reader to the social and historical setting? Yes, please!

It’s such a pleasure to watch Sarah transform from haughty gentlewoman to practical, open-minded Australian. She struggles to learn to sew and do some cooking, skills she never had to master as an English lady. She learns to be thoughtful in her speech patterns, realizing that she can get further with careful statements than her old autocratic declarations. A turning point is when her servant goes into labor – something Sarah realizes she would not even have known about in England – and only Sarah is there to help. Alan has less growing to do, but he’s a good, hard-working man, with historically accurate pride.

The tone of this story is much more old-fashioned than I would have expected given its 2003 release date, reading almost like an Australian Georgette Heyer. The dialogue is enjoyably historical-formal. After Sarah tells Alan she does not expect to see him again (a jab at his low social class and the different circles she expects to move in), Alan retorts:

“Unless your health is perfect, or you are willing to settle for some half-trained leech from The Rocks, then you and your brother are likely to encounter me on a number of occasions. I bid you good day and good health – you are likely to need both.”

The downside of this voice is that by the end, there’s a lot of “clasping” and “my darlings”, which feel a bit silly. I didn’t love the ending action sequence, which relied on a huge coincidence, but it is completely consistent with this sort of older style (think The Scarlet Pimpernel, etc).

Now let’s talk setting. For me, setting is as much about the ‘feel’ and character of the place as it is historical details, and this book shines in both. An Unconventional Heiress reads like a truly Australian story, rather than a UK Regency transplanted to Australia, and the small-town, edge-of-the-world vibe of Sydney comes through. Everyone knows everyone’s business within days, if not hours. Sarah’s dresses, nearly a year out of date, are the closest thing anyone has seen to the latest London fashions. We hear about the heat, the “topsy-turvy” seasons, the wildness of the landscape, the brickyard dust kicked up by the Macquarie building boom, the strangeness of seeing a wallaby in your back garden, the lack of fine food.

This story centers well-researched conflict within the white Australian community. Aboriginal Australians are not erased, but they are peripheral. Governor Macquarie is a real historical figure, long considered the father of Australia for his long-sighted realization that the emancipists who stayed would be the true shapers of the country. (Macquarie is rightfully controversial today for having ordered massacres of Aboriginal Australians, but it’s hard to criticize this book too much for omitting that since they are still, in book terms, six years in the future). Alan is the embodiment of Macquarie’s vision, and it’s touching when Sarah notes that Alan came by force, and she is a guest, but her children will belong to Australia. But alongside those two living Macquarie’s dream, we see people opposed to it, and we also see some of the convicts, especially the political convict Irish, for whom Macquarie’s proposed reforms don’t go far enough.

I love category romances, and it’s always delightful to unbury a Harlequin treasure. If you are looking for a richly-developed unusual setting and a story with old-fashioned (rather than old-skool) vibes, pick up An Unconventional Heiress.

Buy it at: Amazon/Apple Books/Barnes & Noble/Kobo

Visit our Amazon Storefront

Grade: A-

Book Type: Historical Romance

Sensuality: Subtle

Review Date: 21/07/19

Publication Date: 09/2003

Recent Comments …

  1. excellent book: interesting, funny dialogs, deep understanding of each character, interesting secondary characters, and also sexy.

I'm a history geek and educator, and I've lived in five different countries in North America, Asia, and Europe. In addition to the usual subgenres, I'm partial to YA, Sci-fi/Fantasy, and graphic novels. I love to cook.

guest

7 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mary Beth
Mary Beth
Guest
07/22/2019 8:59 am

I read a lot of Paula Marshall’s books many years ago. Tom Dilhorne, a character we meet in An Unconventional Heiress, is the hero in Hester Waring’s Wedding which is also a very good read.

@ elaine s – I loved An Unexpected Passion. That book sent me down a wikipedia rabbit hole!

CarolineAAR
CarolineAAR
Guest
Reply to  Mary Beth
07/22/2019 11:23 am

I liked Hester Waring but it wasn’t as Australian as this – it felt like it could have been a Regency set in London without changing the story. It is still a good read but in an industry with a lot of Regencies, the setting made this jump out to me.

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
07/21/2019 3:28 pm

I feel like we don’t get a ton of romance from this time frame; I know there were some HQN historicals set in this time period. Good work, Caroline!

CarolineAAR
CarolineAAR
Guest
Reply to  Lisa Fernandes
07/21/2019 5:23 pm

The setting was why I originally picked this up. I was delighted that it was so good because you’re right; it is unusual. And cool! I would love to see more!

Lisa Fernandes
Lisa Fernandes
Guest
Reply to  CarolineAAR
07/22/2019 1:52 pm

Same!

elaine s
elaine s
Guest
07/21/2019 4:15 am

Good heavens, a blast from the past! I read many of her books years ago but the best one, IMO, was An Unexpected Passion. It’s based on a true story and very well told. Worth seeking out.

CarolineAAR
CarolineAAR
Guest
Reply to  elaine s
07/22/2019 11:24 am

Now I need to look for that!