TEST
Beverly Jenkins’ Always and Forever is the first historical romance with African-American characters that I have read. I really enjoyed the unusual perspective and the wealth of historical detail. On the other hand, the main characters never grabbed me, and the plot, though mostly enjoyable, made a late, sharp turn that seemed out of place. On balance, I enjoyed the book pretty well, but with some reservations.
Grace Atwood is an educated, cultured paragon of society amongst Chicago’s wealthiest black families. She’s efficient and organized, and at 30 she runs her late father’s bank in 1884 Chicago. When her gold-digging fiancé jilts her for a wealthier bride, Grace decides to get away from it all by accepting an unusual challenge from her cousin: she will select and escort 35 mail-order brides to his fledgling community in Kansas. Leery of Jim Crow laws that frequently leave black travelers stranded by the railroad tracks, Grace chooses to lead the women in an arduous wagon-train journey. To do this she needs a man to protect the all-female group. She finds Jackson Blake, a sheriff-turned-wanted man on the run who burns to avenge his father’s murder in Texas.
The wagon train portion of the book is very entertaining. The author has a knack for presenting crowd interactions, and the women’s experiences make interesting reading. Unfortunately, late in the book the plot veers south to Texas, and to Jackson’s rather clichéd quest for revenge. I would much rather have lingered over the more unusual wagon train setting and focused more closely on the women’s daily life.
Grace and Jackson were also problematic for me. From the first moment, when Grace locates Jackson in a whorehouse and he assumes she’s one of the girls, their physical attraction moves at a brisk pace. Grace’s loving aunts even encourage her to have a fling with Jackson; while this is unusual advice for a historical it seemed plausible given Grace’s age. But while the lust between the two was obvious, I didn’t feel that their emotional attachment was well-developed. As their physical relationship progressed I always felt they were getting ahead of themselves; I would have liked to read more of their emotional development.
The best thing about this book is the historical and cultural setting. The character’s backgrounds often confounded my expectations. It seems as if most historical novels I’ve read either ignore African-Americans entirely or present the absolute worst case scenario. While the worst cases are definitely stories that deserve to be told, I appreciated the careful distinctions this book made depending on characters’ circumstances at a given moment. Grace leads an almost aristocratic lifestyle in Chicago, and Jackson was an elected sheriff in Texas. They encounter appalling racism in their travels but also find respect and kindness from unexpected quarters. Grace and Jackson are realistic about the limitations that racism imposes on them; they know they will not always receive justice and are more realistically concerned with self-preservation than many historical romance couples. The dramatic potential of the cultural conflicts was very clear. I learned a lot but never felt lectured to, and would very gladly read other books set in this time period.
While Always and Forever has problems with plot and characterization, it’s definitely worth reading if you’re interested in an aspect of history that few romance novels ever touch upon.
Grade: B-
Book Type: Frontier/Western Hist Romance
Sensuality: Hot
Review Date: 08/10/00
Publication Date: 2000
Recent Comments …
Yep
This sounds delightful! I’m grabbing it, thanks
excellent book: interesting, funny dialogs, deep understanding of each character, interesting secondary characters, and also sexy.
I don’t think anyone expects you to post UK prices – it’s just a shame that such a great sale…
I’m sorry about that. We don’t have any way to post British prices as an American based site.
I have several of her books on my TBR and after reading this am moving them up the pile.